Friday, February 8, 2013




I think what I am learning from my classes now is to be open to change and to try to encourage and engage my clients to do the same.  It may be a difficult task as I have my own ideas on how to meet with my clients and yet I am being exposed to different ways to do this.  One of the current challenges I am facing is working with ICWA; their goal is to maintain the Indian child with their family; however it is not always so easy as often the child’s parent is no longer connected to their family who are no longer connected to the tribe so in effect, we skip the parents and move on to the extended family for that connection.  The difficulty I face is that staying or introducing a child to their extended family may not always be healthy because that family may be living the same life as their parents who would be dysfunctional or unhealthy otherwise the Department wouldn’t have gotten involved.  So what do we do; do we work at keeping the child connected to the tribe and introducing them to a family member they may not know or supporting them in their current placement which is probably their permanent placement choice and the child may not have any connection to their tribe.  My dilemma is whose interest is most important?  Do we consider the tribe because they want to keep their young tribal members connected because in all cultures it is our youth that will be able to make changes and strengthen our culture or is it the youth’s best interest.  Often they may be more connected to a non-tribal member family; i.e. their foster family and we don’t want to disturb that connection either as that is their strongest connection.  What do we do?  Best interest of child or best interest of tribe?       


4 comments:

  1. You have given us some really powerful information and some great questions this week Deidra. I wish I had the answers. Working in the schools I see and hear a lot of things about the hardships the children are going through and the generational abuse that is occuring. I wonder if it is in the best interest of the child to remain in these circumstances. I wonder how we can better work with the tribe to improve these circumstances. I wish we were able to reach a point where the best interest of the child and tribe were the same. I know each tribe, child and circumstances are different so it seems the solution would be different for each as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Deidra~

    You bring up a very controversial topic! I admire that :) In Serenity's class one of the books has a personal story about a parent Mrs Cruz. Did you read it? I think like the social worker in that story we need to ask ourselves to look at the bigger picture, disregarding our own bias, My thoughts are that the child should stay with their tribe, it is vital to have social workers on and in that res who are of that tribe or are advocates of that tribes culture. I believe we should embrace the family (tribe) as whole. I of course could be wrong...but this is my opinion. It is a hard question you pose with no easy answers.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your post makes me think about this situation and Dr. Phil's interpretation of ICWA...

    http://www.nativenewsnetwork.com/american-indians-outraged-at-dr-phils-insensitivity-of-indian-child-welfare-act.html


    I wonder if we step back from individual cases.. where we are emotionally bound.. can we identify the intent behind the legislation? Who is it meant to protect? I think you ask great questions Deidra... this is a hard situation.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Deidra, Great Post, I can definately read your emotion in your writing. I personally have not had enough exposure to ICWA. I do think the concept of keeping Indian children with Indian families within Indian communities is a grand philosophy. However; in order for this system to benefit children, families, and tribes, other issues need to be looked at as well such as housing, substance abuse, and economic development. Unfortunately there are too many of these risk factors being presented to the parents and their extended family members creating a lack of healthy stable homes available for Indian children. I applaud your efforts for working within this system and for acknowledging that the system needs to consider the individuals involved.

    ReplyDelete